The file never says how many cans
The FDA keeps every report it gets of someone getting sick after a food or supplement. 766 of them name an energy drink, and 73 list a death. That sounds like an answer to “can an energy drink kill you?”, so we read the file to see what it can actually tell you.
The data
The reports come from CAERS, the FDA’s adverse-event system for foods and supplements, published in bulk by openFDA. We counted a report when one of the products it names as a suspect is an energy drink: Monster, 5-hour Energy, Red Bull, or another energy brand. Each report counts once.
| brand named | reports | list a death |
|---|---|---|
| 5-hour Energy | 267 | 43 |
| Monster | 161 | 21 |
| Red Bull | 55 | 3 |
| Every other energy drink | 290 | 8 |
A few reports name two brands and count for both, which is why the rows add up to a little more than 766 and 75 rather than 73.
What one report says
Report 111857, filed in April 2009, names a Monster energy drink, and its outcome just says death. It is on page 1 of the FDA’s own log of energy-drink reports, released under a freedom-of-information request. The same page says these reports “do not represent any conclusion by FDA about whether the product actually caused the adverse events”. A report is someone telling the FDA something happened. It is not a finding.
What you can actually check: the caffeine
A regular 16 oz Monster has 160 mg of caffeine. The FDA says 400 mg a day, counting coffee and everything else, is not generally linked to negative effects for most healthy adults: that is 2.5 cans. It also says toxic effects like seizures can happen with rapid consumption of around 1,200 mg: 7.5 cans, taken fast.
Why the reports can’t settle it
Since December 2007 the law has made supplement makers report serious adverse events to the FDA within 15 business days. Drinks sold as beverages have no such duty. 5-hour Energy is sold as a supplement, so it has to file every one; Monster was labelled a supplement until March 2013; Red Bull never was. So the brand with the most reports is partly the brand that was required to send them.
Reports also follow the news. 5-hour Energy got about 2.5 a month from January 2011 to October 2012. On 14 November 2012 the New York Times reported that FDA reports named it in 13 deaths, and by New Year there were 28 more.
Enough caffeine taken fast can seriously hurt you. But the file never says how many cans anyone drank.
The part that argues against us
“Lists a death” is not “caused a death”. The outcome field records what happened to the person, not what did it.
Reports are not a rate. Nobody has to report a sickness after a drink sold as a beverage, while a news story or a legal duty can multiply the reports for one brand, so the counts say little about how often it happens.
Counts are by the date the FDA created the report, not the date anything happened, and the latest year is partial.
The caffeine figures are for most healthy adults, not for kids or teens, and some people are more sensitive.
Get the data
Free: every energy-drink report in the file counted by year, by brand, and by month around the 2012 news, plus the methodology.
766 reports · 4 brands · the methodology write-up
Sources: FDA CAERS adverse-event reports via the openFDA bulk export (public domain); FDA FOI 14-17, “CAERS Reports Allegedly Related to Multiple Energy Drinks”, page 1 (via cspi.org); FDA consumer update “Spilling the Beans: How Much Caffeine Is Too Much?”; the 160 mg on the 16 oz Monster label; the New York Times, 14 November 2012. Images in the video: “Monster Energy drinks 03.jpg” and “Red Bull energy drinks.jpg” by Oto Zapletal, “Monster Energy Mega can.jpg” by DYVER (all CC BY-SA 4.0, Wikimedia Commons, adapted and shared under the same licence); “5 Hour Energy (9421531605).jpg” by Trailers of the East Coast (CC BY 2.0); the FDA logo (public domain). Music: “Investigations” Kevin MacLeod (incompetech.com), licensed under Creative Commons: By Attribution 4.0, https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/. Sound effects: the Sonniss GDC Game Audio Bundle. Analysis and figures: reelgorithm.py.