# Can an energy drink actually kill you? — methodology

**Source.** The FDA's adverse-event reports for foods and supplements (CAERS), openFDA bulk export
`food-event-0001-of-0001.json` (151,589 reports, public domain). A report counts for an energy drink when one of
its SUSPECT products names Monster, 5-hour Energy, Red Bull or another energy-drink brand (Rockstar, Bang, Celsius, Reign,
NOS, Full Throttle, AMP, Alani, Ghost, C4 Energy, or the words "energy drink" / "energy shot"), minus pre-workout powders,
shampoos and meal shakes that share a brand word. Every matched brand name was checked by eye.

**The numbers in the video.**
- **766** unique reports name an energy drink, 2003–2026 by the year the FDA created them (2026 runs to the end
  of the file, so it is partial). **73** of them list a death among their outcomes.
- The report on screen: No. 111857, filed 2009-04-07, product "MONSTER ENERGY DRINK", outcome "Death",
  from FDA FOI 14-17, 'CAERS Reports Allegedly Related to Multiple Energy Drinks', page 1, via cspi.org/sites/default/files/attachment/foia-energy-drinks.pdf. The same page says these reports "do not represent any conclusion by FDA about whether the product
  actually caused the adverse events".
- One 16 oz Monster: **160 mg** of caffeine (the label). The FDA: **400 mg** a day is "not generally
  associated with negative effects" for most healthy adults, counting coffee and everything else = **2.5** cans;
  "toxic effects, like seizures, can be observed with rapid consumption of around **1,200 milligrams**" = **7.5**
  cans. (FDA consumer update "Spilling the Beans: How Much Caffeine Is Too Much?")
- 5-hour Energy: **2.5** reports a month from January 2011 to October 2012, then **28** from the
  New York Times story of 2012-11-14 (FDA reports naming it in 13 deaths) to New Year.

**Why the reports can't settle it.** Since 2007-12-22 the Dietary Supplement and Nonprescription Drug Consumer Protection Act (P.L. 109-462) makes supplement makers report
serious adverse events within 15 business days; drinks sold as beverages have no such duty. 5-hour Energy is a
supplement, so it files every one; Monster moved from Supplement Facts to Nutrition Facts in 2013-03.
Reports also jump when a brand is in the news (stimulated reporting), and none of them records how many cans anyone drank.

**Traps.**
- A report naming two brands counts once in the by-year file and once for EACH brand in the by-brand file, so the brands
  add up to slightly more than 766.
- "Lists a death" means Death is among the report's outcomes. It is not a finding that the drink caused it.
- Counts are by the date the FDA created the report, not the date anything happened.

**Credits.** Data: FDA CAERS via openFDA (public domain); FDA FOI 14-17 log, page 1 (via cspi.org). Monster can photo:
"Monster Energy drinks 03.jpg", Oto Zapletal (Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 4.0), background removed; Monster claw: "Monster Energy
Mega can.jpg", DYVER (CC BY-SA 4.0); Red Bull: "Red Bull energy drinks.jpg", Oto Zapletal (CC BY-SA 4.0); 5-hour Energy: "5 Hour Energy (9421531605).jpg",
Trailers of the East Coast (CC BY 2.0). Music: "Investigations" Kevin MacLeod (incompetech.com), licensed under Creative Commons:
By Attribution 4.0, https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
