reelgorithm

The mileage is not the money

A hybrid usually gets better mileage. Whether it saves you money is a different question, and the answer depends far more on which car you start from than on the hybrid itself. We took every 2026 car the EPA lists and compared the same model as gas and as hybrid.

The data

The EPA and the Department of Energy publish every new car’s fuel economy at fueleconomy.gov, along with what it costs to fuel for a year: 15,000 miles, 55% of them in town, at the EPA’s current fuel price. Every dollar figure here is that EPA number, not ours. We kept every 2026 gas, diesel, flex-fuel and hybrid configuration and left out electric, plug-in and fuel-cell cars, since the question is gas against hybrid.

The data
826
2026 gas and hybrid configurations
234
Of them hybrids
$3,100
A year to fuel the F-150 in the video
$1,100
A year for the Prius, the cheapest

The truck in the video is a 2026 Ford F-150 4WD with the 2.7 L V6, its cheapest plain-gas 4WD version: 20 mpg combined, $3,100 a year. The ten cheapest nameplates to fuel, each at its best version, are all hybrids:

#carmpgfuel a year
1Toyota Prius57$1,100
2Hyundai Elantra Hybrid54$1,150
3Kia Niro53$1,150
4Hyundai Sonata Hybrid51$1,200
5Toyota Camry51$1,200
6Toyota Corolla Hybrid50$1,250
7Honda Civic Hybrid49$1,250
8Honda Accord Hybrid48$1,300
9Honda Prelude44$1,400
10Lexus UX43$1,450

The same car, gas against hybrid

That ranking says hybrids are cheap to run. It doesn’t say what switching saves, because a Prius has no gas version to switch from. So we took the 12 nameplates sold both ways in 2026 with the same drive, the cheapest-to-fuel version of each side, and subtracted.

carmpg, gas → hybridfuel a yearhybrid saves
Hyundai Santa Fe24 → 36$2,600 → $1,750$850
Toyota Highlander24 → 35$2,600 → $1,800$800
Ford Maverick26 → 38$2,400 → $1,650$750
Kia Sorento26 → 37$2,400 → $1,700$700
Kia Sportage28 → 42$2,200 → $1,500$700
Honda Accord32 → 48$1,950 → $1,300$650
Toyota Corolla34 → 50$1,850 → $1,250$600
Hyundai Tucson28 → 38$2,200 → $1,650$550
Honda CR-V30 → 40$2,100 → $1,550$550
Honda Civic36 → 49$1,750 → $1,250$500
Ford F-15020 → 23$3,100 → $2,700$400
Toyota Tacoma21 → 23$2,950 → $2,700$250

A hybrid Santa Fe saves about $850 a year. The hybrid F-150 saves $400 and the Tacoma $250, because the hybrid trucks only gain 3 and 2 mpg.

Why the thirsty cars save the most

What you pay for gas runs on gallons, and gallons run on 1 ÷ mpg. Going from 24 to 36 mpg cuts a third of the gallons; going from 36 to 49 cuts about a quarter of far fewer gallons. So the Civic gains 13 mpg, more than the Santa Fe’s 12, and still saves less: $500 against $850, because the gas Civic was already cheap to fill up ($1,750 a year against $2,600). Judging cars by mpg instead of gallons has a name: the MPG illusion (Larrick and Soll, Science, 2008).

A hybrid saves you the most when it adds a lot of mileage to a car that drinks gas.

The part that argues against us

What this is not

It is fuel only. Not the price gap between the two cars, insurance, repairs or resale, so it says nothing about how fast a hybrid pays for itself.

It is the EPA’s driver. 15,000 miles a year at the EPA’s fuel price. Drive twice as much and every saving doubles.

The pair depends on the versions. We compared each side’s cheapest-to-fuel version. The F-150’s middle gas 4WD version costs $3,300 a year to fuel, not $3,100, and against that the hybrid would save $600. The hybrid F-150 also has a bigger engine (3.5 L) than the gas one compared (2.7 L).

Get the data

Free: the 12 gas-against-hybrid pairs, every 2026 configuration the EPA lists, and the methodology.

The hybrid vs gas data

12 pairs · 826 configurations · the methodology write-up

Open the data kit

Sources: EPA / U.S. Department of Energy, fueleconomy.gov vehicles.csv, model year 2026, downloaded 4 November 2026 (public domain); R. Larrick and J. Soll, “The MPG Illusion”, Science 320 (2008). Images in the video: “2024 Ford F-150 XLT front view.jpg” by Deathpallie325 (CC BY-SA 4.0), background removed and wheels redrawn, shared under the same licence; “Honda Civic 2.0 RS HEV Hybrid 2025 (1).jpg” by Captainmorlypogi1959 (CC BY-SA 4.0), drawn as text art, shared under the same licence; “2025 Toyota RAV4 Hybrid Adventure.jpg” by TTTNIS (CC0) and “2023 Toyota Prius Z PHEV.jpg” by TTTNIS (CC0), drawn as text art (all Wikimedia Commons); maker logos used to identify the cars. Music: “Investigations” Kevin MacLeod (incompetech.com), licensed under Creative Commons: By Attribution 4.0, https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/. Sound effects: Epidemic Sound. Analysis and figures: reelgorithm.py.